Understand drug prices
Generic vs brand-name drugs
Choosing a generic is one of the most reliable ways to pay less for a prescription. Yet many people still wonder whether a generic is really the same as the brand. This guide explains how the FDA approves generics, what "therapeutically equivalent" means, where generics can differ, and how much they typically save.
Key takeaways
- A generic has the same active ingredient, strength, dosage form and route as the brand.
- The FDA requires generics to be bioequivalent, meaning they deliver the drug to the body in the same way.
- Products rated "A" (for example "AB") in the Orange Book are considered therapeutically equivalent and can generally be substituted.
- Inactive ingredients, shape and colour can differ, which matters for some allergies and intolerances.
- Your prescriber can require the brand by writing "dispense as written".
- Generics usually cost a fraction of the brand price.
What makes a generic a generic
A brand-name drug is approved through a New Drug Application, which includes full clinical trials. Once its patents and exclusivity periods end, other companies can apply to sell a generic version through an Abbreviated New Drug Application (ANDA). "Abbreviated" means they do not have to repeat the original clinical trials. Instead, they must show that their product is the same as the brand in the ways that matter:
- Same active ingredient
- Same strength
- Same dosage form (tablet, capsule, injection and so on)
- Same route of administration
- Same conditions of use and essentially the same labeling
- Manufactured to the same FDA quality standards
Generic manufacturing sites are inspected by the FDA in the same way as brand sites. In fact, some brand companies make generics too, and some generics are made in the same facilities as brands.
Bioequivalence explained
To be approved, a generic usually has to show bioequivalence to the brand. In a typical study, healthy volunteers take the brand and the generic, and researchers measure how much of the drug reaches the bloodstream and how fast. The FDA sets statistical limits for how closely those measurements must match. If the generic falls within them, it is expected to have the same clinical effect and safety profile as the brand.
For some products, such as inhalers, creams or complex injectables, showing equivalence takes different kinds of studies, which is one reason generics for those products can be slower to arrive.
Therapeutic equivalence and the Orange Book
The FDA publishes a reference called Approved Drug Products with Therapeutic Equivalence Evaluations, better known as the Orange Book. For each approved generic, it gives a therapeutic equivalence code:
- Codes beginning with "A" mean the FDA considers the product therapeutically equivalent to the reference drug. "AB" is the most common, used where bioequivalence has been shown.
- Codes beginning with "B" mean the FDA does not currently consider the product therapeutically equivalent, often because of unresolved bioequivalence questions.
State laws on substitution generally rely on these ratings. In most states, pharmacists can substitute an A-rated generic for a brand unless the prescriber or patient says otherwise. FairPill shows Orange Book information on drug pages, including patents, which you can read about in when will a generic be available.
Inactive ingredients and appearance
Generics can differ from the brand in their inactive ingredients - the fillers, binders, dyes, coatings and preservatives that hold a tablet together or make a liquid stable. US trademark law also means a generic usually cannot look identical to the brand, so the colour, shape and markings may be different.
For most people these differences do not matter. But they can matter if you have an allergy or intolerance to a specific ingredient, such as a dye, lactose or gluten. If that applies to you, ask your pharmacist to check the inactive ingredients of the specific product you are getting. They may also be able to request a particular manufacturer.
A change in pill appearance can also be confusing. If your refill looks different, it may simply be from another generic manufacturer. Ask your pharmacist to confirm before you take it.
Dispense as written
A prescriber can indicate that the brand must be dispensed, often written as "dispense as written" (DAW) or "brand medically necessary". Pharmacies then cannot substitute a generic. Patients can also request the brand. Be aware that if you have insurance and request the brand when a generic is available, your plan may charge you more or not cover it.
For a few medicines where small differences in blood levels can matter, prescribers sometimes prefer to keep a patient on the same product consistently. If you have questions about this for your own medicine, ask your prescriber or pharmacist rather than changing anything yourself.
Authorized generics
An authorized generic is the brand-name drug itself, made under the brand's original approval, but sold without the brand name. It may be marketed by the brand company or by a partner. It typically has the same inactive ingredients as the brand, and it often launches around the time the first standard generics arrive. Authorized generics can be useful if you have tolerated the brand well and would like the same formulation at a lower price.
How big is the price gap?
The difference can be dramatic. The FDA has said that generics typically cost 80% to 85% less than the brand. For many common medicines, such as atorvastatin, lisinopril and metformin, the pharmacy's acquisition cost is often only cents per tablet. Prices tend to fall most when several generic makers compete. When only one or two companies make a generic, the savings can be smaller.
Our drug pages show brand and generic acquisition costs where both are on the market. Note that an FDA approval does not always mean a generic is on sale: for example, generic versions of Eliquis (apixaban) have been approved, but patent settlements have delayed their US launch. Browse by drug class on the classes page to see generic options in the same group of medicines.
How to ask about a generic
- Ask your pharmacist: "Is there an A-rated generic for this medicine?"
- If not, ask your prescriber whether a different medicine with a generic would be suitable for you.
- If you have allergies or intolerances, ask the pharmacist to check the generic's inactive ingredients.
- Look up the generic's acquisition cost and fair cash price on FairPill.
- Compare your quote using the price checker.
For more ways to save, see how to pay less for prescriptions without insurance and questions to ask your pharmacist. If you have switched to a generic recently, you can share what you paid to help others see the difference.
This guide is general information, not medical or financial advice. Talk to your pharmacist or prescriber about your own medicines.
Questions about this guide
No comments yet. Questions, tips, what worked for you - start the conversation.